top of page
Turf Versus Artificial Grass for Edinburgh Gardens

Turf Versus Artificial Grass for Edinburgh Gardens

Oct 31
6 min read

A new lawn can make a tired garden look properly finished, but turf versus artificial grass is not simply a question of which one looks greener on the day it is laid. Edinburgh gardens deal with wet weather, shaded corners, compact ground and regular use from children, pets and garden furniture. The right choice depends on how the space is used, how much maintenance you want to take on and, above all, whether the ground is prepared correctly.

Turf versus artificial grass: the main difference

Turf is real grass supplied in cut rolls and laid over prepared topsoil. Once rooted, it becomes a living lawn that changes with the seasons. It has the natural feel, scent and appearance many homeowners want, but it needs watering while it establishes and regular cutting thereafter.

Artificial grass is a man-made surface fitted over a constructed base. Good-quality products can look convincing, remain green throughout the year and remove the need for mowing. However, they still need cleaning and brushing, and a poor installation can lead to puddles, wrinkles, movement at the edges and weeds pushing through joins.

Neither option is automatically better. A sunny family garden with room for a mower may suit turf brilliantly. A small, shaded back garden where natural grass has repeatedly turned muddy may be far more practical with artificial grass.

When real turf is the better choice

For homeowners who want a natural, softer garden, turf is difficult to beat. A healthy lawn feels cool underfoot in summer and provides a living surface that changes through the year. It can also be repaired more naturally than synthetic grass. Thin patches can be overseeded, uneven areas can be levelled and worn sections can be returfed.

Turf is often the sensible option where drainage is already good, the area receives a reasonable amount of daylight and the lawn will not be under constant heavy use. It is particularly suited to larger gardens, where the natural look helps tie beds, trees, shrubs and patios together.

The trade-off is upkeep. Grass needs mowing through the growing season, feeding when required, edging, occasional aeration and weed control. Newly laid turf also needs careful watering until the roots have taken hold. If the lawn is laid in poor soil or onto ground that has not been levelled and prepared, it can struggle regardless of how good the turf itself is.

Timing matters too. Turf can be laid at different points of the year when conditions are suitable, but very hot, dry spells create more watering work. In cold or saturated conditions, the ground may need attention before laying can begin.

Turf works well if you want to use the garden naturally

Real grass is a good match for gardeners who do not mind a bit of regular work and enjoy maintaining their outdoor space. It is also a strong choice where children use the garden occasionally rather than every day in the same spot. If a football goal, trampoline or paddling pool sits in one place for long periods, expect some wear and plan for repairs.

For landlords and property owners preparing a home for sale, turf can give a garden a fresh, natural appearance at a sensible initial cost. It does need a maintenance plan afterwards, though. A neglected real lawn quickly loses the tidy finish that made it appealing in the first place.

When artificial grass makes more sense

Artificial grass is often chosen for gardens where natural turf simply will not thrive. Deep shade from fences, mature trees or neighbouring buildings can leave real grass thin and mossy. Narrow city gardens may also receive heavy foot traffic in a small area, leaving mud at the back door during wetter months.

A properly fitted artificial lawn gives a consistently neat appearance without mowing, watering or feeding. It can be useful around patios, play areas and seating spaces where people want to use the garden without waiting for wet grass to dry. It is also popular for holiday lets, rental properties and busy households that want the look of a lawn with less day-to-day work.

That does not mean artificial grass is maintenance-free. Leaves, soil and debris should be removed, especially in autumn. The pile benefits from an occasional brush to keep it standing evenly. Pet mess needs dealt with promptly, and the area may need rinsed and cleaned to prevent smells. Choosing a pet-friendly product and making sure the base drains well are both essential.

Artificial grass can also feel warmer in direct sun and is not the same as walking on a real lawn. Quality varies greatly. Cheap products may look overly bright, flatten quickly or feel rough, while a good product has a more natural mix of tones and a suitable pile height for its intended use.

The installation is as important as the grass

Most problems with artificial grass come from what is underneath it. The old surface must be removed to the correct depth, the ground shaped for drainage and a stable sub-base installed and compacted. A suitable membrane helps reduce weed growth, while the edges need secured neatly against paving, timber, sleepers or fencing.

If water has nowhere to go, an artificial lawn can still become waterlogged. If the base is uneven, the finished surface will show every dip and bump. This is why it is worth looking at the whole garden rather than treating artificial grass as a quick cover-up for poor ground conditions.

Cost, maintenance and long-term value

Turf usually costs less to install than artificial grass, particularly when the existing soil is in reasonable condition. The ongoing cost is higher in time and maintenance: mowing equipment, watering, lawn feed, seed and occasional repair all add up over the years.

Artificial grass normally has a higher upfront price because of excavation, base preparation, drainage materials, edging and the product itself. Its ongoing maintenance is lower, but it is not zero. It will eventually show wear, especially in busy areas, and replacing it later involves lifting and disposing of the old material.

It helps to compare like for like when asking for quotes. A low artificial-grass price may leave out excavation, waste removal, sub-base materials or proper edging. Equally, a turf quote should make clear whether it includes removing weeds, bringing in quality topsoil, levelling the ground and the first cut or aftercare advice. A clear quote protects the finished result as much as the budget.

Drainage should decide more than appearance

In Edinburgh and the Lothians, drainage deserves close attention before choosing either surface. A garden that stays wet for days after rainfall may have compacted soil, an incorrect fall, blocked drainage routes or a low point collecting water. Laying new turf over the problem will not fix it, and fitting artificial grass without a correctly built base can make the issue harder to spot until puddles appear.

For real turf, improving the soil structure and levelling the area may be enough. In more difficult gardens, drainage channels or other groundworks may be needed. For artificial grass, the base should allow water to pass through and move away without damaging nearby paving, walls or property foundations.

A site visit is the best time to identify these details. It also gives you the chance to consider access for materials, existing steps, retaining edges, flower beds and whether the lawn needs to work alongside a new patio, path or fence.

Think about how you actually use the garden

Before choosing, picture the garden in November as well as July. If you want somewhere for children and pets to play without bringing mud indoors, artificial grass may be worth the higher initial outlay. If you enjoy gardening, value a living lawn and have the time to look after it, turf delivers a finish artificial materials cannot fully copy.

There is also a middle ground. Some gardens work best with a smaller real lawn surrounded by paving and planted beds, reducing the area that needs cut. Others benefit from artificial grass near the house and natural planting elsewhere. The best layouts do not force one material into every corner.

For a lasting finish, start with the ground, not the sample book. Whether you choose fresh turf or artificial grass, careful preparation, sound drainage and tidy edges will make the garden easier to enjoy long after the work is complete.

 
 
 

Comments


Featured Posts

Recent Posts

Archive

Search By Tags

Follow Us

  • Facebook Basic Square
  • Twitter Basic Square
  • Google+ Basic Square

K Vincent Plastering & Landscaping Edinburgh
25 Linden Avenue
Edinburgh EH16 6FA
Mobile: 07960431645
Email: kev.vincent@hotmail.co.uk

 

© 2019 by K Vincent Plastering Edinburgh & Landscapers Edinburgh | Services We Cover

  • Facebook - Black Circle
  • Twitter Round
  • b-googleplus
bottom of page